Effects of connection deformation softening on behavior of steel moment frames subjected to earthquakes

In the years since the 1994 Northridge earthquake, the profession has paid significant attention to the potential effects of various forms of deterioration in connection strength and stiffness that steel moment-resisting frames can experience during severe seismic excitations. The brittle connection fractures that a number of welded steel moment-resisting frame structures experienced during recent earthquakes have been the most extensively studied to date. However, cyclic testing of post-Northridge beam-column connections demonstrates that ductile connections may suffer other forms of deterioration. Negative post-yield tangent stiffness or capping, hereafter referred to as deformation softening, is a behavior of particular interest because it may have significant adverse effects on frame system behavior. The effects of deformation softening on frames subjected to pulse excitations were examined as part of an integrated experimental and analytical investigation of the effect of various forms of hysteretic deterioration on the overall system behavior of moment resisting steel frames. Pulse excitations, and the near-field ground motions they represent, can be highly damaging to structures and are therefore the primary focus of the results presented in this paper. The experimental portion of this study consisted of a series of thirty-two shaking table tests, which were performed on a one-third scale, two-story, one bay, steel moment frame with idealized, mechanical connections. These tests and subsequent analytical studies show that, in general, significant loss of connection strength capacity, whether from deformation softening or other types of deterioration, leads to large residual drifts and, for large pulse excitations with durations longer than the fundamental period of the structure, to collapse. In particular, frames with connections exhibiting negative post-yield stiffness tend to have substantially increased peak and residual displacements when subjected to pulse excitations.