Paleovegetation and paleo-pedogenic properties from the upper Miocene Coffee Ranch fossil site in the North American Great Plains

Abstract Modern physical and chemical soil properties can favor or exclude C3 and C4 plants, yet little is known regarding these relationships from deep-time records that track the evolution and expansion of C4 vegetation. In this study, we used a multi-proxy approach to reconstruct vegetation (C3 vs. C4 biomass) and pedogenic properties (soil alkalinity, salinity, sodicity, and texture) from paleolandscapes at Coffee Ranch, Texas, a site from which fossil horses provide the earliest evidence for C4 herbivory in the Great Plains of North America. Local proportion of C4 biomass was assessed using stable carbon isotope ratios of calcium carbonates (δ13Ccc) and organic matter (δ13Com) analyzed on four different paleosol types, freshwater tufa, and reworked carbonate nodules in fluvial channel lags. Using a Monte Carlo uncertainty analysis, we interpret δ13Ccc (range = −8.5 to −5.2‰ VPDB) and δ13Com values (range = −25.9 to −24.2‰ VPDB) to be consistent with C4 biomass low in abundance and variability at the study site, but with large uncertainties that would be overlooked using simple linear mixing model approaches. Paleo-pedogenic properties were reconstructed using pedotransfer functions and provide evidence of possible salinity and sodicity in two of five paleosol profiles. However, saline-sodic conditions and soil texture were not correlated with δ13C values, contrary to some modern mixed C3-C4 biomes. Using late Miocene CO2 and paleoclimate model reconstructions, we argue that conditions were at or near crossover thresholds favoring C4 over C3 photosynthesis in the Great Plains despite the low abundance of C4 vegetation across the paleolandscapes. This study presents evidence that abiotic factors that select for C4 plants in modern systems—high growing season temperature, low atmospheric CO2, salinity-sodicity, and soil texture—were less influential in the late Miocene than biotic factors (i.e., ecological feedbacks) that suppressed C4 plants prior to their increase in abundance in the Great Plains in the Pliocene.