Induction of humoral and cellular immunity to simian immunodeficiency virus : what are the requirements for protection ?

Abstract In an effort to produce a strong humoral and cellular immune response that might protect against simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) infection, groups of five rhesus macaques each were immunized intramuscularly at 0, 2 and 6 months with 100 μg of an inactivated preparation of SIV/Delta B670 in either an oil-in-water emulsion with Ribi Detox, containing mycobacterial cell wall skeleton and monophosphoryl lipid A (CWS/MPL) (group A) or a water-in-oil emulsion with incomplete Freund's adjuvant, containing CWS/MPL for the first two injections (group B). Animals were challenged with 10–100 monkey ID 50 of monkey-cell-grown SIV mac251 3 months after the last injection, along with a group of four unvaccinated controls. Group B animals demonstrated the strongest immune responses following immunization, including neutralizing antibody titres against the challenge virus ranging from 160 to 320 and SIV-specific ELISA titres ranging from 10 5 –10 6 on the day of challenge, as well as strong in vitro lymphoproliferative and interleukin-2 (IL-2) production responses to the immunogen. Neutralizing antibody was not detectable in group A animals. ELISA titres were lower (10 2 –10 4 ), no in vitro lymphoproliferative responses were observed, and in vitro IL-2 production was less pronounced. No protection against challenge was observed in either group. Moreover, group B animals exhibited a more pronounced clinical response following challenge than either group A animals or controls, consisting of hyperthermia and a greater degree of lymphadenopathy on day 7, followed by hypothermia and generally higher levels of serum viraemia on day 14. Together with other studies, these findings suggest that alternative immunization strategies, using non-infectious SIV immunogens, should be explored in an effort to lock the immune response to SIV into a cell-mediated mode.