Does mechanical site preparation affect trembling aspen density and growth 9–12 years after treatment?

Trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) density and growth were assessed 9–12 years after stand establishment to determine whether mechanical site preparation (MSP) affects crop tree quality. Study sites were either treated with disc trenching or ripper ploughing and planted with white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss) seedlings immediately after harvest (treated) or were undisturbed since harvest (control). Stands were surveyed during the summer of 2002 with standard regeneration survey plots. Results show that aspen stem density and height were lower in MSP-treated areas relative to untreated areas. Diameter growth rates were unaffected by treatment, however the percentage of stem discolouration was higher in untreated control stands compared to site prepared areas. The results of this study indicate that there are no long-term benefits to carry out MSP for aspen promotion. However, as MSP does not appear to seriously harm the aspen crop, we suggest that this treatment can still be used on sites where aspen densities may be low without treatment (e.g., sites with extremely low soil temperatures, poor soil aeration, or vigorous competitive vegetation) or where a mixture of aspen and planted spruce are desired.