Forests are among the most important habitats of the Earth for several ecological reasons and their management is a prior task when dealing with landscape conservation.Thematic maps and remote sensing data are powerful tools to be used in landscape planning and forest management; nevertheless, most of the European and Mediterranean forest monitoring and conservation programs do not take into account the continuity of the variation of habitats within the landscape but they only rely on boolean classification methods.The utilisation of a classification method that applies a continuity criterion is fundamental because it is expected to better represent the ecological gradients within a landscape.The aim of this paper is to assess the amount of classification uncertainty related to crisp (boolean) classes, particularly focusing on forest identification uncertainty.Forest fuzzy membership of the Tuscany region (Italy) derived from a Landsat ETM+ image scene was compared with the widely used crisp datasets in European forests management and conservation practices, i.e. the European JRC Forest/Non-Forest map, the CORINE Land Cover 2000 (levels 1 and 2), as well as the Global Land Cover 2000, in order to qualitatively and quantitatively assess the separability of crisp classes with respect to forest fuzzy membership.A statistically significant (p < 0.001) forest fuzzy membership separability among the considered crisp classes was found.Despite the crisp dataset and hierarchical level taken into account, both forest and non-forest crisp classes showed a high degree of forest fuzzy membership variability.Therefore, given the intrinsic mixture of crisp land cover classes, ecological studies on forestal ecosystems should rigorously take into account the classification uncertainty related to a crisp view of ecological entities which are being mapped.
EnglishComparison between crisp and fuzzy methods in mapping forested areas. - Forests represent one of the most important habitats of the Earth for several ecological reasons, hosting a great amount of Earth biodiversity, preventing soil erosion, replenishing ground water by reducing water runoff, controlling flooding enhancing infiltration, storing carbon. Thematic maps and remote sensing data are powerful tools to be used in landscape planning and forest management. Most of the European and Mediterranean forest monitoring and conservation program only rely on boolean classification methods. The aim of this paper was to assess the amount of classification uncertainty related to crisp classes, particuiarly focusing on forest identification and mapping. Forest fuzzy membership of the Tuscany region (Italy) was obtained by a Landsat ETM+ image and compared with the most used crisp datasets in European Forests management and conservation plans (i.e. the European JRC Forest/Non-Forest map and the CORINE Land cover 2000, levels 1 and 2), in order to qualitatively and quantitatively assess the separability, of crisp classes whith respect to forest fuzzy membership. A statistically significant (p Meanwhile, despite the crisp dataset and hierarchical level taken into account, forest crisp classes showved a high degree of forest fuzzy, membership variability. While, on the one hand operational problems associated to spatial resolution were remarked, on the other the intrinsic mixing of crisp land cover classes suggests to take into account the uncertainty related 1o a crisp view of ecological entities which are being mapped. francaisComparaison des methodes crisp et fuzzy dans la cartographie des forets. - Les sont une des principales reserves de biodiversite sur notre planete et leur fragmentation est consideree l'une des plus grandes menaces pour la diminution de la biodiversite globale, resultant en une reduction significative des habitats adequats pour les especes sensibles et donc en une extinction rapide des populations au niveau local. Afin de developper des strategies pour la conservation, et la gestion durable des forets, il est important d'obtenir la cartographie des types de a travers des methodes de classification objective, caracterisees par un faible niveau d'incertitude. Toutefois, la plupart des projets de conservation et de gestion des sont bases sur la cartographie crisp traditionnelle, fondee sur la logique booleenne, et caracterisee par un niveau eleve d'incertitude. Le but de cette etude est d'evaluer l'incertitude des principaux programmes de cartographie Crisp disponibles au niveau europeen (CCR et de la SIC de niveau 1 et 2), grace a une approche fuzzy. La methodologie proposee prevoit la classilication fuzzy d'une image Landsat ETM+ de la Region Toscane, afin de classer les superficie forestieres en fonction de leur degre d'appartenance a la categorie foret. Les classes crisp, derivees de dataset utilisees, ont ete compares en fonction du degre d'appartenance a la categorie des forets et les resultats obtenus ont ete valides par un test non parame_ trique. Les resultats montrent une separabilite statistique de toutes les classes utilisees, mais en meme temps on a trouve une grande variabilite dans les classes de foret, ce qui demontre l'incertitude intrinseque des methodes traditionnelles crisp pour l'identification des differentes categories de forets, en particulier dans les environnements avec haute conplexite structurelle.
Abstract In connectivity conservation and ecological network planning, the selection of focal fragmentation-sensitive species represents an a priori step. Despite their strategic role, selection of focal species has often been carried out following non-objective approaches. If this is done, actions of planning and conservation, especially in relation to biodiversity conservation, could be ineffective. We propose an expert-based approach to select focal species on the basis of sensitivity to three components of habitat fragmentation (habitat area reduction, increase of habitat isolation, increase of edge effect and landscape matrix disturbance) and of intrinsic ecological traits of the species (trophic level, dispersal ability, body size, niche breadth, rarity). A case study on terrestrial mammals of an area in Central Italy (province of Rome) shows that the species selected through this approach largely coincide with the species recognized in the literature as being fragmentation-sensitive. In this paper we present a conceptual framework to select focal species and to define a schematic methodology for ecological network planning and monitoring.
Negli ultimi anni, un crescente interesse nei confronti della biodiversità e della sua conservazione ha portato allo sviluppo di nuovi metodi per la classificazione della superficie terrestre (Goodchild 1999, Rocchini & Ricotta 2007).La classificazione delle immagini satellitari e lo sviluppo di modelli predittivi della distribuzione delle specie o degli habitat sono approcci classici che consentono di sviluppare efficaci politiche di conservazione (Roloff & Haufler 1997, Felix-Locher & Campa 2010).Lo sviluppo di modelli per la classificazione degli habitat forestali rappresenta un importante supporto alla pianificazione, in quanto le foreste costituiscono la tipologia di habitat maggiormente diffusa sulla superficie terrestre e occupano un ruolo cruciale nella
The effectiveness of biodiversity conservation strategies depends on the knowledge about the distribution of habitats or single species.Despite this, efforts on biodiversity monitoring and conservation are currently hindered by a lack of information about the spatial distribution of species on large landscapes.Predictive species distribution models, can provide a powerful tool for solving this ecological problem.The vast majority of data available for modelling plants distribution are herbarium data, which lack reliable records of species absence.Although it has been found that herbarium records do not meet current standards for sampling in ecological studies, they remain often the only available source of sufficient magnitude with regard to relevant distribution data.Modifying existing statistical tools and developing new methods so that herbarium data, despite their shortcomings, can be used for modelling habitat suitability, is currently a growing field.The aim of this paper was to analyse the opportunities and bottlenecks for future application of distribution models in the mapping and monitoring of habitats of conservation interest in a complex Mediterranean area.Here we specifically concentrate on testing the Maximum entropy (Maxent) approach to estimate the distribution of a training habitat through the use of herbarium records and to explore a GIS-based integrated approach.The results obtained highlighted the important role that distribution models can have in individuating the areas where a targeted species or habitat type is most likely to be found, and in showing where to commit the limited available resources for inventories.