Challenge 9: Towards an Ocean-Engaged Society
José PintadoAna Crespo SolanaEva Balsa‐CantoElisa BerdaletSalvador Bernabéu AlbertAlbert CalbetJuan Francisco GibajaXavier GarcíaElías López-RomeroManuel Lucena GiraldoM. Pilar MartínLuisa Martínez LorenzoJavier Martínez VegaConsuelo Naranjo OrovioGabriela Ojeda RomanoEstrella OlmedoJosé L. OviedoAnanda PascualJaume PieraJuan PimentelMiguel Ángel Puig-SamperMiquel Àngel Rodríguez AriasValentı́ SallarèsCristina Sánchez-CarreteroKaren SoachaJoaquı́n Tintoré
0
Citation
0
Reference
20
Related Paper
Cite
Cite
Citations (15)
Colonial rule in Africa privileged Western Knowledge Systems (WKS), discredited Indigenous Knowledge Systems (IKS) and provided the context for the fashioning of 'scientific knowledge' about Africa. The exigencies of the colonial political economy determined priorities in the creation of scientific knowledge about the African environment; hence reports abounded on mining, forestry, and farming. Fishing was a latecomer in colonial economic considerations, and this neglect was inherited by post-colonial African governments. This paper examines the vibrant maritime fishing industry that developed along the West African coast, in spite of the absence of initial colonial support, and the production of a veritable 'citizen science', where fishing was concerned. The fishing industry has come under close international and national regulation in the last decade or two with recommendations to diversify from the fisheries sector and to promote fish farming as an alternative to freshwater and marine fisheries. This paper explores the transferability of indigenous knowledge to this new sphere and highlights the need to privilege the concerns and needs of fishing communities, as fishing is more a way of life than just a livelihood. It advocates aligning community, national and international interests and concerns in developmental agendas.
Traditional Knowledge
Fishing industry
Cite
Citations (13)
South Africa is currently the world’s third most biodiverse country, with one of the highest concentrations of threatened biodiversity in the world. Emerging research reveals the increasing pressure on this biodiversity with many wild resources continuing to be utilised for livelihood purposes even within urban environments. The Rio conventions, particularly the CBD, call for an integrated approach to conservation that incorporates local environmental knowledge and practices. In a bid to market itself as globally competitive, South Africa’s Curriculum 2005 (C 2005) is primarily focused on Western-based scientific knowledge, which sidelines the contribution of indigenous knowledge systems (IKS) and ignores the holistic nature of indigenous worldviews. The Inkcubeko Nendalo programme is designed to revitalise cultural identity, showing children the value of local indigenous knowledge and cultural environmental values. The programme is currently being implemented at seven schools in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. The project’s contribution to local community environmental and heritage awareness, successes and challenges are discussed both at a local level and in response to the objectives signed in the Convention of Biodiversity (CBD) and sustainable development. The project offers solutions to not only effective local environmental education but also sustainable integrated community conservation practices, revealing that the maintenance of biodiversity and natural vegetation is as much in the interest of local communities’ well-being as it is of global conservation planners.
Traditional Knowledge
Local Community
Cite
Citations (9)
The delimitation of Bangladesh’s maritime boundary with her neighbouring states has defined a clear geopolitical boundary and established state’s jurisdiction over ocean resources in the northernmost Bay of Bengal. Different initiatives and activities were subsequently undertaken in the coastal and marine areas, which showcase a collective interest within different state agencies to explore the potentials of blue economy in Bangladesh. Despite multitude of interpretations assigned to ‘blue economy’ concept by scholars, this study aims to reveal a localized narrative of blue economy in the context of Bangladesh. It also explores how that localized narrative and current trajectories may impact the marginalized marine fishing communities whose very livelihoods depend on fishing in the Bay of Bengal.
The study uses data from a literature review, interviews with experts, government officials and development workers, and focus group discussions with fishing communities to understand the underlying blue economy narrative and how it may affect the livelihoods of marine fishing communities in future. This research uses the blue economy narratives proposed by Silver et al. (2015) and Voyer et al. (2018) as a framework to identify the underlying discourse in Bangladesh. Then, common property rights and ecological distributive justice lenses have employed to understand the possible interactions between emergent blue economy discourses and marine fisheries sector.
The analyses reveal that the state has undertaken different extractive and exploitative endeavours to develop the undeveloped or unused ocean space, foregrounding a growth agenda. Using national growth and market expansion logics, a clear priority has been made to expand a capitalist ocean with little regards for environmental safety and social equity. However, it is not clear how different state agencies will attain the expected growth because the novel economic frontiers require high technical capacities, skilled manpower, private sec-tor involvement and investments, and effective coordination.
Among traditional maritime activities, marine fisheries sector provides the largest number of employments to coastal communities. However, their safety at sea, access to formal financial sectors, conflicts with industrial fishing units, lack of supports during fishing ban seasons remain unaddressed for years, current activities under blue economy seek to strengthen the monitoring and surveillance capacity of different state agencies in order to effectively enforce fisheries management rules. It was found that there is no clear strategy or framework to guide a marine spatial planning process and effective governance when it is expected that the coastal and marine space will be industrialized to fulfil a growth agenda set by the state.
To conclude, the state’s current blue economy narrative may bring national growth upon overcoming different challenges, but at the cost of environmental safety and the livelihoods of marginalized fishing communities.
Geopolitics
Cite
Citations (0)
Safeguarding
Ratification
International community
Values
Cite
Citations (31)
The South Pacific region is both bio-diverse and rich in cultural heritage. The two areas not isolated and indeed it has been said that biological and cultural diversity are ‘inextricably linked’. This can be illustrated by the use that has been made of biodiversity by Indigenous peoples and the traditional ecological knowledge that has developed throughout the region. Most of these countries have progressed some way towards establishing legislative frameworks for Indigenous land and marine tenure, rights in relation to natural resources and protected area management. However much is left to be done in relation to legal regimes to prevent the degradation and exploitation of bio-cultural heritage. This paper will examine the international law that supports the conservation and sustainable use of bio-cultural heritage and in particular draw attention to the need for greater interconnectedness between the Conventions on Biodiversity and the Safeguarding of Intangible Heritage. In conclusion the paper will highlight the challenges that remain to ensure that the integrity of bio-cultural heritage is secured for the present and future generations.
Safeguarding
Cite
Citations (1)
This paper addresses the impacts of globalization on cultural heritage conservation in sub-Saharan Africa. The homogenization and commodification of Indigenous cultures as a result of globalization and it’s impacts on the devaluation of heritage sites and cultural properties is discussed within a Nigerian context. Additionally, the ongoing global demand for African art objects continues to fuel the looting and destruction of archaeological and historical sites, negatively impacting the well-being of local communities and their relationships to their cultural heritage. Global organizations and institutions such as UNESCO, the World Bank, and other institutions have been important stakeholders in the protection of cultural heritage worldwide. This paper assesses the efficacy of the policies and interventions implemented by these organizations and institutions within Africa and makes suggestions on how to advance the protection of African cultural heritage within the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Furthermore, cultural heritage conservation is explored as a core element of community well-being and a tool with which African nations may achieve sustainable economic development.
Commodification
Looting
Cite
Citations (6)
Indigenous peoples are asserting their right to build their own and be part of contemporary environmental governance structures. This has been a complicated challenge and one overlain with an ongoing fight to combat the legacy of colonisation and reassert sovereignty and rights the world over. This paper examines the role Indigenous peoples play in marine and coastal governance, and discusses some of the current challenges facing them in asserting their rights in marine spaces. We find that there are a range of features which could be described as specific to Indigenous governance, and also that there have been a number of factors that affect, in one way or another, the implementation of both Indigenous driven or co-managed governance in marine spaces. Nonetheless we argue that key features of Indigenous governance and practice not only play a key role in the assertion of Indigenous management of their own marine estates, but also have the potential to contribute to wider marine governance structures.
Colonisation
Assertion
Indigenous Rights
Cite
Citations (22)
Marine conservation
Cite
Citations (19)
Abstract Marine and coastal zone policy represents a collaboration of people managing and people managed. This paper takes a holistic stance in suggesting that marine communities are viewed properly as networks of focused interest groups, policymakers, professionals, and publics. The interplay between culture and marine and coastal policy is appropriately one topic of applied social research. Seven ethnographic studies in this domain are introduced in this theme issue and help us to understand sociocultural processes and institutions bearing on marine affairs.
Theme (computing)
Publics
Cite
Citations (6)