Modification of methane oxidation pathways during long-term incubations of methanic lake sediments

Abstract. Anaerobic oxidation of methane (AOM) is one of the major processes limiting the release of the greenhouse gas methane from natural environments. In Lake Kinneret sediments, iron-coupled AOM (Fe-AOM) was suggested to play a substantial role (10–15 % relative to methanogenesis) in the methanic zone (> 20 cm sediment depth), based on geochemical profiles and experiments on fresh sediments. Apparently, the oxidation of methane is mediated by a combination of mcr gene bearing archaea and aerobic bacterial methanotrophs. Here we aimed to investigate the survival of this complex microbial interplay under controlled conditions. We followed the AOM process during long-term (~18 months) anaerobic slurry experiments of these methanic sediments with two stages of incubations and additions of 13C-labeled methane, multiple electron acceptors and inhibitors. After these incubation stages carbon isotope measurements in the dissolved inorganic pool still showed considerable AOM (3–8 % relative to methanogenesis). Specific lipid carbon isotope measurements and metagenomic analyses indicate that after the prolonged incubation aerobic methanotrophic bacteria were no longer involved in the oxidation process, whereas mcr gene bearing archaea were most likely responsible for oxidizing the methane. Humic substances and iron oxides are likely electron acceptors to support this oxidation, whereas sulfate, manganese, nitrate, and nitrite did not support the AOM in these methanic sediments. Our results suggest in the natural lake sediments methanotrophic bacteria are responsible for part of the methane oxidation by the reduction of combined micro levels of oxygen and iron oxides in a cryptic cycle, while the rest of the methane is converted by reverse methanogenesis. After long-term incubation, the latter prevails without bacterial methanotropic activity and with a different iron reduction pathway.