Ecological separation versus geographical isolation: population genetics of the water‐lily leaf beetle Galerucella nymphaeae (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae)

Many sedentary species with specific habitat demands occur in isolated populations and thus show strong intraspecific genetic differentiation, shaped either by geographical isolation or by local ecological adaptation to specific environmental conditions. The water-lily leaf beetle Galerucella nymphaeae has two ecotypes: one only found feeding as a specialist on just a few host plant species of the family Polygonaceae, and the other on various representatives of the family Nymphaeaceae as a generalist. To test whether the differentiation in ecotypes is also reflected in the population genetic structure, we combined amplified fragment length polymorhism data (> 500 polymorphic fragments; four sampling sites, 27–31 individuals each) with ex-situ feeding experiments (ten individuals from each site). We found that both ecotypes are genetically well differentiated. Furthermore, the genetic divergence between the two studied generalist Nymphaeaceae ecotype populations was also high. In contrast, the two specialist Polygonaceae ecotype populations clustered closely together (thus not depending on geographical isolation), indicating an ecology-driven genetic structuring. Our ex-situ reciprocal feeding experiment revealed that only individuals of the Polygonaceae ecotype are strictly dependent on their host plant family: individuals from populations feeding Polygonaceae are less likely to feed on species from the family Nymphaeaceae than the reverse. Our data show that host preference may drive genetic differentiation even more strongly than simple geographical distance.