Tree canopy cover constrains the fertility-diversity relationship in plant communities of the southeastern USA.

The goal of elucidating the primary mechanisms constraining the assembly and distribution of biodiversity remains among the central unresolved challenges facing the field of ecology. Simulation studies and experimental manipulations have focused on how patterns in community assembly result from bivariate relationships along productivity or environmental gradients. However, the joint influence of multiple resource gradients on the distribution of species richness in natural communities remains under-studied. Using data from a large network of multi-scale vegetation plots across forests and woodlands of the southeastern US, we find significant evidence for the scale dependent, joint constraints of forest structure and soil resources on the distribution of vascular plant species richness. In addition to their significant partial effects on species richness, understory light levels and soil fertility positively interact, suggesting a trade-off between the two limiting resources with species richness peaking both in high-light, low-fertility conditions as well as low-light, high-fertility settings. This finding provides a novel perspective on the biodiversity-productivity relationship that suggests a transition in limiting resources from soil nutrients to light availability when enhanced productivity results in reduced light resources for subordinate individuals. Results likewise have meaningful implications for our understanding of scale dependent community assembly processes as size-asymmetric competition replaces environmental filtering as the primary assembly mechanism structuring temperate forest communities along an increasing soil fertility gradient.