Does endoesophageal ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration replace mediastinoscopy in mediastinal staging of thoracic malignancies?

Objective: To determine the impact of endoesophageal ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration (EUS-FNA) on management of thoracic malignancies. Methods: One hundred and twenty patients referred for invasive diagnostic and resection of thoracic malignancies were studied prospectively. Negative and inconclusive EUS-FNA findings were assessed by video-assisted mediastinoscopic lymphadenectomy (VAMLA) or open lymphadenectomy. Results: One hundred and twenty patients, aged 64.1 years (range 38—85) underwent 120 EUS-FNA, 53 video-assisted mediastinoscopic and 48 open lymphadenectomies for diagnosis and treatment of 99 lung carcinoma, six lung metastases, five mesothelioma, three lymphoma, and eight other conditions. EUS-FNA showed T4 in 15/120 and adrenal or hepatic metastases in 9/120 cases. Prevalence of mediastinal lymph node metastases was 51.7%. EUS-FNA false-negative rate was 25.3%. EUS-FNA sensitivity was 91.7%, 78.1% and 43.8% for bulky disease, enlarged mediastinal nodes or normal nodes on CTscan, 50% and 96.6% for right- and left-sided tumours, and 80.6%, 78.9%, 23.8% and 25.0% for the lymph node stations 7, 5/6, 4R, and 4L. A 38.3% respectively 100% cut-down of mediastinoscopiesleads in 7.5% respectively 20.8% to incorrect treatment decisions. Conclusions: EUS-FNA sensitivity depends on the localisation of the primary tumour, and extent and location of mediastinal disease. For left-sided tumours, EUS-FNA improves mediastinal staging by assessing stations 5 and 6 inaccessible to conventional mediastinoscopy. Forextended mediastinal disease,mediastinoscopycan beavoidedorsparedfor restagingafterneoadjuvanttherapy. Exclusion of mediastinal involvement requires mediastinoscopy or open lymphadenectomy. Beyond mediastinal nodal staging, EUS-FNA may detect T4 and M1 situations. Thus, EUS-FNA is a useful supplement to and not the replacement of mediastinoscopy. # 2008 European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.