Performance Portability Evaluation of OpenCL Benchmarks across Intel and NVIDIA Platforms

We evaluate the capabilities of vendor-provided OpenCL implementations for performance portability across multiple computing platforms. The Rodinia benchmark suite is used for this evaluation. We apply the metric defined by Pennycook et al., and we use roofline efficiency from the Roofline performance model as the “performance efficiency” in the metric's definition. We found that the delivered performance portability is similar for several benchmarks, even if the roofline-based performance efficiencies across platforms are very different among the benchmarks. To help distinguish between these instances, we extend the metric by adding the standard deviation of the performance efficiencies for each benchmark. We argue that the standard deviation gives additional insight into performance portability assessment since it adds the performance variability across platforms. Additionally, we discuss the challenges to measure performance portability associated with algorithms and system software. In terms of algorithms, we need to carefully construct the benchmarks and appropriately use the concurrency available on a platform. In terms of system software, we depend on the vendor performance tools to support the desired programming model and runtime to be able to measure the metrics of interest.