Towards an efficient rule-based framework for legal reasoning

Abstract A rule based knowledge system consists of three main components: a set of rules, facts to be fed to the reasoning corresponding to the data of a case, and an inference engine. In general, facts are stored in (relational) databases that represent knowledge in a first-order based formalism. However, legal knowledge uses defeasible deontic logic for knowledge representation due to its particular features that cannot be supported by first-order logic. In this work, we present a unified framework that supports efficient legal reasoning. In the framework, a novel inference engine is proposed in which the Semantic Rule Index can identify candidate rules with their corresponding semantic rules if any, and an inference controller is able to guide the executions of queries and reasoning. It can eliminate rules that cannot be fired to avoid unnecessary computations in early stages. The experiments demonstrated the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed framework.