Refractory nature of normal human diploid fibroblasts with respect to oncogene-mediated transformation

Human cells are known to be more refractory than rodent cells against oncogenic transformation in vitro. To date, the molecular mechanisms underlying such resistance remain largely unknown. The combination of simian virus 40 early region and H-Ras V12 has been effective for transformation of rat embryo fibroblasts, but not for human cells. However, the additional ectopic expression of the telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT) was reported to be capable of causing transformation of normal human cells. In this study, however, we demonstrate that the combined expression of the above-mentioned three genetic elements is not always sufficient to transform normal human diploid fibroblasts (HDF). Although the expression and function of these introduced genetic elements were essentially the same, among four HDF, TIG-1 and TIG-3 were resistant to transformation. The other two (BJ and IMR-90) showed transformed phenotypes, but they were much restricted compared with rat embryo fibroblasts in expressing simian virus 40 early region and H-Ras V12. In correlation with these phenotypes, TIG-1 and TIG-3 remained diploid after the introduction of these genetic elements, whereas BJ and IMR-90 became highly aneuploid. These results strongly suggest that the lack of telomerase is not the sole reason for the refractory nature of HDF against transformation and that normal human cells have still undefined intrinsic mechanisms rendering them resistant to oncogenic transformation.