Diagnosis of cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease in renal allograft recipients: the role of semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR)

Background. Cytomegalovirus disease remains a significant cause of morbidity and mortality in the renal allograft recipient. There is a need for rapid and sensitive techniques predictive of CMV disease to allow initiation of early antiviral therapy. Methods. Seventy-seven renal allograft recipients were enrolled in a prospective study where CMV viruria (shell vial culture/DEAFF test), viraemia (shell vial culture), serology and detection of virus DNA in peripheral blood leukocytes by PCR (CMV DNAemia) were correlated with clinical evidence of CMV disease. Results. Serology and shell vial culture had poor sensitivity for the early diagnosis of CMV disease. CMV DNAemia appeared to correlate with active virus replication. CMV DNAemia had a sensitivity and negative predictive value of 100% and a positive predictive value of 27% for CMV disease. Patients with symptomatic CMV disease were shown to have higher levels of CMV DNAemia than those with asymptomatic infection. Conclusions. A negative CMV DNAemia result excluded CMV disease with confidence, but a positive result (given the low positive predictive value) did not by itself provide a reliable guide for the initiation of pre-emptive antiviral therapy. However, the semiquantitative CMV DNAemia result taken together with the clinical findings provided useful information for patient management.