Monoclonal Expansion with Integration of High-Risk Type Human Papillomaviruses Is an Initial Step for Cervical Carcinogenesis: Association of Clonal Status and Human Papillomavirus Infection with Clinical Outcome in Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia

To define the natural history of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) as related to clonal status, we evaluated 20 cases of CIN1 and 18 cases of CIN2 that had been clinically followed for 7 to 48 months at Osaka University Hospital. These included 10 cases that progressed, 15 cases that persisted, and 13 cases that regressed. We analyzed the clonal status of each case by analysis of the pattern of X-chromosomal inactivation. Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection was detected by PCR-RFLP analysis. CINs that are monoclonal or infected by high-risk HPVs are more likely to progress or persist than cases that are polyclonal or negative for high-risk HPVs (p = 0.009 for monoclonal vs polyclonal, p = 0.024 for high-risk HPV positive vs negative p = 0.024). Eighteen (90%) of 20 monoclonal, high-risk HPV-associated CINs progressed or persisted, whereas 9 (60%) of 15 polyclonal or high-risk HPV-negative CINs regressed. Therefore, the combination of clonality status and high-risk type HPV infection was significantly correlated with clinical outcome (p = 0.003). The physical status of the HPV genome was evaluated in 17 cases of HPV-16 positive CINs by real-time PCR. Of those, the HPV viral genome was present in both episomal and integrated forms in 14 CINs (84%), and 12 of these cases (86%) were monoclonal in composition. By contrast, all three CINs in which the HPV genome was present in episomal form were polyclonal. In one CIN1 that was polyclonal, HPV-16 was originally present in episomal form but after 24 months, the patient developed a monoclonal CIN3 in which the HPV-16 genome was present in mixed form. These results may imply that HPV viral integration into the host genomic DNA is associated with progression from polyclonal to monoclonal status in CIN. These events may play a fundamental role in the progression from low-grade to higher grade dysplasia of the cervical mucosa.