Impact of Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) Predation on the Crayfish Orconectes virilis in Three Michigan Lakes

The crayfish Orconectes virilis is a major component of the benthos of three small lakes in northern Michigan. These lakes contained stocked brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) populations (age-0 and age-I) at densities of 188, 411, and 1398 fish/ha. Crayfish were preyed upon by brook trout, but only during their first year of life. Two-year production of age-0 crayfish was approximately 94 kg in each lake; brook trout consumed only about 1–2% in lakes with lower density offish. Even with greater trout density and accompanying higher rate of exploitation (40%), there was no impact on recruitment of young crayfish because compensatory mortality of crayfish occurred in lakes with less trout predation. However, stocking trout at higher densities decreased trout growth and condition. While 2-yr production was highest (59 kg/ha) in the lake stocked at the highest density and lowest (17 kg/ha) in one stocked at the lowest density, the former was achieved at the cost of a very slow growing trout population. Most...