Can overstorey retention be used to control bramble (Rubus fruticosus L. agg.) during regeneration of forests

Summary Silvicultural systems which retain canopy cover during the regeneration phase have become an increasingly important form of management, but their effectiveness in controlling weed species has not been extensively studied. The development of bramble, which is a widespread competitive weed species, was observed within a c. 35-year-old Corsican pine stand thinned to remove 10, 20, 40 and 80 per cent of basal area. Cover, height and numbers of inflorescences and berries were recorded in each of the 3 years following thinning and were generally ranked according to intensity of thinning, but there were no significant differences between treatments. Shoot length, estimated using a grid-intersection method, was significantly lower in the 10 per cent compared with the 40 and 80 per cent thinning treatments. The initial length of bramble shoot present, and basal area and number of trees remaining could be used in various combinations to predict cover, height and shoot length. Although the bramble thicket was generally less well developed in the less-intense thinning treatments, these did not appear to enhance the establishment of trees. Seedlings grew best in the 80 per cent treatment and overall their mean heights were generally lower than that of bramble. Retention of overstorey cover in order to suppress bramble growth and promote tree seedling establishment during forest regeneration may not succeed.