Graft Position and Pulmonary Function After Single Lung Transplantation for Obstructive Lung Disease

Single lung transplantation (SLT) has become a therapeutic option for the treatment of end-stage obstructive lung disease. Between January 1989 and June 1990, there were 14 patients with end-stage obstructive lung disease who underwent SLT. Eleven of these patients were surviving at 1 year following transplantation. Three of the patients had received left-sided SLT, and eight had received right-sided SLT. In the patients receiving left-sided SLT, the native right lung radiographically appeared to compress the left lung graft. In the patients receiving right-sided SLT, the native left lung did not appear to compress the right lung graft. We hypothesized that right SLT may provide a functional advantage over left SLT for patients with obstructive lung disease. We compared pulmonary function test results before and after transplantation (approximately 3 and 12 months) and compared quantitative ventilation-perfusion lung scan results between the patients with left SLT and those with right SLT. Additionally, we compared graded-exercise test results at 3 and 12 months after transplant between the two groups. Our data revealed no statistical difference in pulmonary function test results or graded-exercise test results between the two groups, although patients undergoing right SLT showed greater increases in FEV 1 and forced vital capacity than those undergoing left SLT. Quantitative ventilation and perfusion were greater to the graft in patients receiving right-sided SLT than in patients receiving left-sided SLT, most likely due to the larger size of the right lung. We conclude that there is no functional difference between patients undergoing left or right SLT for end-stage obstructive lung disease.