Involving users in the refinement of the competency-based achievement system: An innovative approach to competency-based assessment

Background: Competency-based assessment innovations are being implemented to address concerns about the effectiveness of traditional approaches to medical training and the assessment of competence.Aim: Integrating intended users’ perspectives during the piloting and refinement process of an innovation is necessary to ensure the innovation meets users’ needs. Failure to do so results in no opportunity for users to influence the innovation, nor for developers to assess why an innovation works or does not work in different contexts.Methods: A qualitative participatory action research approach was used. Sixteen first-year residents participated in three focus groups and two interviews during piloting. Verbatim transcripts were analyzed individually and then across all transcripts using a constant comparison approach.Results: The analysis revealed three key characteristics related to the impact on the residents’ acceptance of the innovation as being a worthwhile investment of time and effort: access to frequen...