Stereotactic thermocoagulation for insular epilepsy: Lessons from successes and failures

OBJECTIVE: To assess factors associated with favorable outcome in refractory insular epilepsy treated by volume-based stereotactic radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFTC). METHODS: We performed volume-based RFTC in 19 patients (11 males, 7-44 years old). The volume for thermocoagulation was identified by multimodal data including electroencephalography (EEG)-video, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography (PET) in all patients, and epileptogenic zone (EZ) was assessed by stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) in 16. MRI showed insular lesions in four patients (benign tumors, n = 2; focal cortical dysplasia [FCD], n = 1; polymicrogyria, n = 1). MRI was negative in 15 cases; however, PET was positive in 18, and FCD pattern was detected by SEEG in nine cases. The dominant hemisphere was involved in 12 cases. RFTC was performed as a separate procedure after SEEG, or as a single MRI-guided procedure. The insular volume to be coagulated was determined by a tridimensional identification of the epileptogenic cortex using MRI, PET, and SEEG, and was destroyed with coalescent thermal lesions. RESULTS: Seizure-free outcome was achieved in 10 patients (53%), including Engel class IA in three (follow-up = 1-12 years, mean = 5.4). The responder rate (including Engel classes I-III) was 89%. Transient postoperative deficits (mild hemiparesia, dysarthria, hypoesthesia, dysgeusia) were observed in eight patients (42%), with rapid and total recovery in all but one with persistent mild dysarthria. Neurological deficits were related to higher number of RFTC procedures (P = .036) and greater volume of RFTC (P = .028). Neuropsychological status was unchanged or improved in all; however, psychiatric status transitorily worsened in three patients. Factors contributing to seizure-free outcome were the detection of FCD pattern (P = .009), localized EZ (P = .038), low RFTC volume (P = .002), low number of RFTC procedures (P = .001), and low RFTC volume/number ratio (P = .012). Optimal volume of RFTC around 2 cm3 offered the best compromise between efficacy and safety. SIGNIFICANCE: RFTC may be curative in insular epilepsy after accurate localization of EZ with SEEG. Best outcome was associated with low volume of thermolesions.