Biomechanical analysis of two insertion sites for the fixation of the sacroiliac joint via an oblique lateral approach

Abstract Background The sacroiliac joint is an important source of low back pain. In severe cases, sacroiliac joint fusion is used to reduce pain, but revision rates can reach 30%. The lack of initial mechanical stability may lead to pseudarthrosis, thus not alleviating the patient's symptoms. This could be due to the damage induced to the interosseous ligament during implant insertion. Decoupling instrumentation steps (drilling-tapping and implant insertion) would allow verifying this hypothesis. Moreover, no biomechanical studies have been published on sacroiliac joint fixation with an oblique lateral approach, while it has important clinical advantages over the direct lateral approach. Methods Eight cadaveric human pelves with both ischia embedded were tested in three sequential states: intact, drilled-tapped and instrumented with one cylindrical threaded implant with an oblique lateral trajectory. Specimens were assigned one of two insertion sites (distal point; near the posterior superior iliac spine, and proximal point; anterosuperior to the distal point) and tested in compression and flexion-extension. Vertical and angular displacements of the sacroiliac joint were measured locally using digital image correlation methods. Findings In compression, instrumentation significantly reduced vertical displacements (17% (SD 22%), P = 0.04) but no difference was found for angular displacements or flexion-extension loads (P > 0.05). Drilling-tapping did not change the stability of the sacroiliac joint (P > 0.05); there was no statistical difference between the insertion sites (P > 0.05). Interpretations Insertion of one implant through either the distal or proximal insertion site with an oblique lateral approach significantly reduced vertical displacements of the sacroiliac joint in compression, a predominant load of this joint. Research ethics committee Polytechnique Montreal: CER-1617-30.