Demonstration of either endogenous recurrence or exogenous reinfection by restriction endonuclease cleavage analysis of herpes simplex virus from patients with recrudescent genital herpes

By using restriction endonuclease (RE) cleavage analysis, either endogenous recurrence or exogenous reinfection of herpes simplex virus (HSV) was clarified in 45 male and 20 female subjects with recrudescent genital herpes. All of the plural (two to ten) isolates from 63 (205 isolates) out of 65 subjects (97%) were HSV-2. Two isolates from only one of 65 subjects (1.5%) were HSV-1, and they showed the same RE profile. In addition, an HSV-1 and five HSV-2 isolates were obtained from the remaining one female patient (1.5%), indicating that an exogenous HSV-1 strain has been reinfected during HSV-2 recrudescences. HSV-2 isolates were furthermore classified into genotypes of HSV-2 using 16 different RE markers with five REs. Two hundred and ten HSV-2 isolates from 64 subjects were classified into 27 distinct genotypes, in which some predominant genotypes and seven new genotypes were found. Plural HSV-2 isolates obtained from 63 out of 64 subjects, including one subject from whom an HSV-1 and five HSV-2 strains were isolated, were classified into the same genotypes, indicating that they may be regarded as recrudescent genital herpes by the reactivation of the same endogenous strain. However, the RE profiles of two HSV-2 strains from the remaining one subject were different. Thus, it was finally found that only two out of 65 subjects (3%) were reinfected with exogenous strains. These results lead to the conclusion that almost all recrudescent genital herpes are due to the reactivation of an initially infected HSV-2 strain, and are occasionally due to reinfection with distinct HSV strains of either the same or a different type. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.