On the question of instabilities upstream of cylindrical bodies

In an attempt to understand the unsteady vortical phenomena in perturbed stagnation regions of cylindrical bodies, a critical review of the theoretical and experimental evidence was made. Current theory is revealed to be incomplete, incorrect, or inapplicable to the phenomena observed experimentally. The formalistic approach via the principle of exchange of instabilities should most likely be replaced by a forced-disturbance approach. Also, many false conclusions were reached by ignoring that treatment of the base and perturbed flows in Hiemenz coordinate eta is asymptotic in nature. Almost surely the techniques of matched asymptotic expansions are expected to be used to capture correctly the diffusive and vorticity amplifying processes of the disturbances regarding the mean-flow boundary layer and outer potential field as eta and y/diameter approach infinity. The serious uncertainties in the experiments are discussed in detail.