Bone reconstruction: subjective evaluation and objective analysis based on conventional digital x-rays - a retrospective evaluation

BACKGROUND Various approaches have been used to evaluate callus stiffness in distraction osteogenesis. This assessment becomes even more critical as inadequate corticalization and premature removal of the frame lead to bending, refracture, and loss of length. This study aimed to verify the objective Pixel Value Ratio (PVR) and define an evaluation scheme to assess callus tissue development during internal and external bone lengthening. HYPOTHESIS There are no differences between subjective parameters and objective evaluation for external and internal bone lengthening. PATIENTS AND METHODS We included 24 patients in this retrospective study, treated by distraction osteogenesis of the lower limb. Ten patients were treated with external ring fixators and 14 with intramedullary lengthening devices. The minimum distraction distance was 3 cm. Callus tissue was evaluated with the PVR, using digital x-rays during and after treatment. We combined this method with subjective evaluation parameters, including the continuity, signal intensity, and the regeneration tissue's homogeneity, presented in the X-ray Evaluation System for Distraction Osteogenesis (XESDO). RESULTS The subjective evaluation showed an increase of continuity and signal-intensity between 4th postoperative weeks and complete healing with significant differences between the external and internal groups for homogeneity only after four weeks and for all parameters at 3C (p<0.05).The PVR showed an increase during consolidation with values between 0.7 and 1.0 for both groups with almost perfect interobserver agreement. Significant lower values were found in the anterior tibial cases. CONCLUSION PVR appears to be a practical tool for radiological evaluation of callus tissue development. In combination with the newly introduced XESDO and the surgeon's experience, these methods can be helpful for decisions during all phases of distraction osteogenesis. It is important for adapting alignment or distraction-rate, as various potential complications can be detected early. However, further studies are necessary to assess the image-based determination of callus tissue stability. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE III; Cohort study.