Functional succinate dehydrogenase deficiency and loss of ascorbic acid transporter SLC23A1 are pathognomonic adverse features of clear cell renal cancer

ABSTRACT Background Reduced succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) activity resulting in adverse succinate accumulation was previously thought to be relevant only in 0.05-0.5% of kidney cancers associated with germline SDH mutations (categorized ‘SDH-deficient Renal Cell Carcinoma’ in the 2016 WHO classification) Results We show that under-expression of SDH subunits resulting in accumulation of oncogenic succinate is a common feature in clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) tumors during pathogenesis and progression, with a marked adverse impact on survival in a large cohort (n=516) of ccRCC patients. From a mechanistic standpoint, we show that von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) loss induced hypoxia-inducible factor (HIF) dependent upregulation of mir-210 in ccRCC causes direct inhibition of the SDHD transcript. We demonstrate that reduced expression of SDH subunits is associated with genome-wide increase in methylation and enhancement of epithelial mesenchymal transition (EMT) in ccRCC tumors, consistent with succinate-induced inhibition of TET activity and increase in invasiveness/ migratory ability of ccRCC cells. TET-2 inhibition-induced global regulatory DNA hypermethylation drives SDH loss-induced enrichment of EMT. SDH subunits under-expression had a striking association with CDHI (E-cadherin) loss in ccRCC tumors, in keeping with succinate-induced CDH1 hypermethylation and under-expression in ccRCC cells. Next, in conformity with recombinant TET-2 fluorescence quenching dynamics with succinate and ascorbic acid (AA, a TET enzyme co-factor), AA treatment led to reversal of succinate-induced inhibition of TET activity, CDH1 hypermethylation and under-expression, as well as enhanced invasiveness in ccRCC cells. Furthermore, using immunohistochemical analysis and artificial intelligence quantitation, we report that ccRCC is characterized by a marked loss of ascorbic acid transporter SLC23A1 [median percent positive cells in ccRCC primary tumors (n=104) and normal kidney cortex (n=7) was 0.7 and 32.4 respectively; p=0.0012]. Lower SLC23A1 was associated with worse survival in ccRCC (TCGA). Lastly, intravenous AA significantly prolonged survival in a metastatic ccRCC xenograft model with increased succinate and reduced SLC23A1 expression. Conclusions Taken together, these findings strongly indicate that functional SDH deficiency is a pathognomonic adverse feature of ccRCC (which accounts for ∼80% of all kidney cancers), and that the WHO category ‘SDH-deficient RCC’ should be re-named ‘SDH germline mutation-associated RCC’. Furthermore, oncogenic accumulation of succinate can be abrogated by TET modulation with AA. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE In this study, we show that under-expression of succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) subunits resulting in the accumulation of oncogenic succinate is a common, adverse, epigenetic modulating feature occurring in a vast majority of clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC), during pathogenesis and progression. Functional SDH deficiency is therefore a pathognomonic feature of ccRCC (which accounts for ∼80% of all kidney cancers), and not just limited to the 0.05-0.5% of kidney cancer patients with germline SDH mutations. Based on the findings reported, we propose that the ‘SDH-deficient RCC’ category in the 2016 WHO classification of kidney tumors be renamed ‘SDH germline mutation-associated RCC’. Furthermore, we demonstrate that oncogenic accumulation of succinate in ccRCC can be countered by TET modulation with ascorbic acid, and that ccRCC is characterized by a marked loss of ascorbic acid transporter SLC23A1.