Non-operative Management (NOM) of Rectal Cancer: Literature Review and Translation of Evidence into Practice

Despite mounting interest in the non-operative management (NOM, also known as watchful waiting) of rectal adenocarcinoma, limited guidance exists regarding appropriate patient selection and procedures. In this literature review targeting patients with operable adenocarcinoma of the rectum, we sought to evaluate NOM in terms of patient selection, management approaches, and outcomes with regard to both quality of life (QoL) and oncologic outcomes. Despite a lack of randomized evidence comparing NOM (performed via active surveillance following neoadjuvant chemotherapy and radiation) to neoadjuvant therapy followed by planned surgery, given that the vast majority of local, regional, and distant recurrences occur early in follow-up, the available evidence points to similar oncologic outcomes and possible QoL improvement. Due to the high chance of surgical salvage in the case of locoregional recurrence, close multidisciplinary follow-up is essential. Under the care of an experienced multidisciplinary lower gastrointestinal team, NOM is feasible, is safe, and has the potential for improved QoL. A potential algorithm for clinically implementing NOM is described within this review.