Performance of radiography and single-photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography in painful total hip arthroplasty and impact on arthroplasty survival.

PURPOSE To investigate the performance of radiography and single-photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography (SPECT/CT) in painful hip arthroplasty regarding loosening and arthroplasty survival. METHODS Radiography and SPECT/CT reports of 249 painful hip arthroplasties of 191 patients were reviewed. Positive imaging was defined if loosening, infection, and polyethylene wear were found, indicating the need for arthroplasty exchange. Median time from radiograph to operation or last follow-up was 41.3 months (range 0.3-118.4 months). In 67 patients, the performance of radiographs and SPECT/CT regarding loosening was compared with an intraoperative reference standard. The time point of arthroplasty exchange exchange was compared with imaging diagnosis and evaluated with Kaplan-Meier curves. RESULTS Exchange of cup, shaft, or both was performed in 76 of 249 arthroplasties. Main diagnoses on SPECT/CT were loosening (n = 94), infection (n = 5), and polyethylene wear (n = 15). In total, 104 patients were SPECT/CT positive compared to 84 patients on radiography. Five-year survival of arthroplasties for radiograph positive and negative arthroplasties was 41.5%/83.4% and 39.3%/90.7% for SPECT/CT, respectively. Prognostic impact regarding arthroplasty exchange was highest in radiograph and SPECT/CT concordant positive patients (hazard ratio 19.7 as compared to radiograph and SPECT/CT negative patients). Sensitivity and specificity in 67 operated patients regarding shaft loosening were 59.4%/80.0% with radiography, 90.6%/68.6% with SPECT/CT (P = 0.002 for sensitivity and P = 0.29 for specificity), and for cup loosening 47.4%/89.6% with radiography and 63.2%/85.4% with SPECT/CT (P = 0.51, respectively, P = 0.63). CONCLUSION In patients with painful hip arthroplasty, positive radiography, and SPECT/CT are associated with poorer arthroplasty survival. Performance regarding loosening is slightly better with SPECT/CT.