Strain evolution in Caenorhabditis elegans: Transposable elements as markers of interstrain evolutionary history

Evolutionary relationships across taxa can be deduced from sequence divergence of proteins, RNA, or DNA; sequences which diverge rapidly, such as those of mitochondrial genes, have been especially useful for comparisons of closely related species, and-within limits—of strains within a species. We have utilized the transposable element Tcl as a polymorphic marker to evaluate the evolutionary relationships among nine Caenorhabditis elegans strains. For five low-Tcl-copy strains, we compared patterns of restriction fragments hybridizing to a cloned Tc1 probe. Twenty of the 40 Tc1 insertion sites thus characterized were common to all five strains, and so presumably preceded strain divergence; the 20 differential bands were used to construct a maximum-parsimony tree relating these strains. In four high-copy-number stocks (three wild-type strains and a subline), we determined occupancy of 35 individual Tc1 insertion sites by a polymerase chain reaction assay. Surprisingly, the high-copy strains share a common subset of these Tc1 insertions, and the chromosomal distribution of conserved Tc 1 sites is “clustered” with respect to the other elements tested. These data imply a close evolutionary relationship among the high-copy strains, such that two of these strains appear to have been derived from the highest-copy-number lineage (represented by two stocks) through crossing with a low-Tc1 strain. Abundances of Tc1 elements were also estimated for the four high-copy-number stocks, at ∼200–500 copies per haploid genome, by quantitative dot-blot hybridization relative to two low-copy strains. Annealing with 32P-labeled probes corresponding to full-length Tc1, an oligonucleotide within the Tc1 terminal inverted repeats, and an internal Tc1 oligonucleotide, gave essentially identical results—indicating that Tc1 termini exist in the genome primarily as components of full-length Tc1 elements. A composite evolutionary tree is proposed, based on the locations and numbers of Tc1 elements in these strains, which is consistent with a four-branch intraspecific tree deduced previously by maximum-parsimony analyses of mitochondrial sequence changes; it also serves to elucidate the evolutionary history of transposon mobility.