Performance evaluation of synthetic and natural polymers in nitrogen foam-based fracturing fluids in the Cooper Basin, South Australia

Hydraulic fracturing is a well-known stimulation technique for creating fractures in a subsurface formation to achieve profitable production rates in low-permeability reservoirs. Slickwater has been widely used as a traditional fracturing fluid. However, it has multiple disadvantages, such as high consumption of water, clay swelling and low flowback recovery. Foam, as an alternative fracturing fluid, consumes less liquid and provides additional energy. However, foam bubbles are typically unstable due to the degradation of surfactants, particularly in high temperature reservoirs, which reduces their capabilities of carrying and placing proppants into fractures. The purpose of this study is to provide general guidelines for an optimised application of polymers to improve the foam stability in high temperature reservoirs while increasing the proppant placement and water usage efficiencies. In this paper, the effects of natural hydroxypropyl guar (HPG) and synthetic polyacrylamide (PAM) polymers on the rheological properties of nitrogen foam-based fluids were examined by laboratory experiments conducted using temperatures up to 110°C. Then, a 3D hydraulic fracture propagation model was developed to study the fracturing performance of HPG-foamed and PAM-foamed fluids in the Toolachee Formation, Cooper Basin. It was found that synthetic PAM polymers were more effective than natural HPG polymers in stabilising foam viscosity under high temperature conditions. The simulation results indicate that foam-based fluids totally outperform slickwater in the field case application. This paper emphasises the significance of crosslinkers, foam quality and thermal stability on the performance of foams in high temperature environments.