Statistical evaluation of potential mistakes and malpractice in a Chest Pain Unit

AIMS: The Chest Pain Unit (CPU) of Policlinico Umberto I, established in 2008, is charged with the management of patients with non-traumatic chest pain transferred from the Emergency Department and aims at: a) an early recognition of patients at high risk of acute coronary syndrome (ACS), in order to perform a primary PCI within 90 minutes; b) an early diagnosis of patients at low risk of ACS in order to discharge them in a short time, and c) the diagnostic performance of clinical tests in patients at intermediate risk of ACS in order to identify those who require either a new PCI or a coronary artery bypass graft (CABG). The purpose is to avoid malpractice which could even imply the risk of legal conflicts. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We evaluated the total number of admissions to the Emergency Department of Policlinico Umberto I in the period 2010-2011 and selected the patients with non-traumatic chest pain and acute coronary syndrome. In the Chest Pain Unit, patients with non-traumatic chest pain or ACS were recruited through a) the use of the Chest Pain Score to define the typicality or atypicality of chest pain; b) the stratification of the risk of ACS using the modified Braunwald Score; and c) the stratification of patients at intermediate or high risk of ACS using the GRACE ACS Model in order to perform a PCI. RESULTS: In the period 2010-2011, 603 patients were admitted to the CPU with non-traumatic chest pain. Of them, 15.75% (95) were diagnosed with atypical chest pain; 27.03% (163) with chronic stable angina pectoris; 9.3% (56) received a diagnosis of chronic heart failure and 47.92% (289) suffered from non ischemic cardiovascular disease. Other 124 subjects were admitted to the CPU with a diagnosis of ACS, but only in 91.93% of the cases such diagnosis was confirmed, whereas for the remaining 8.06% was discarded. On the whole, 54.2% (394) of the 727 patients admitted to the CPU with non-traumatic chest pain and acute coronary syndrome showed a low cardiovascular risk; 30.12% (219) were at intermediate risk and 15.68% (144) at high risk. DISCUSSION: The aim of the CPU is to accomplish a selection of the subjects at high risk of ACS, to drastically reduce the time of diagnosis and treatment to 24-36 hours and to avoid possible mistakes or adverse events by using both unsophisticated diagnostic tests and a personalized management of diagnosis and treatment.