Dual domestication, diversity, and differential introgression in Old World cotton diploids

Domestication in the cotton genus is remarkable in that it has occurred independently four different times at two different ploidy levels. Relatively little is known about genome evolution and domestication in the cultivated diploid species Gossypium herbaceum and G. arboreum, because of the absence of wild representatives for the latter species, their ancient domestication, and their joint history of human-mediated dispersal and interspecific gene flow. Using in-depth resequencing of a broad sampling from both species, we confirm their independent domestication, as opposed to a progenitor-derivative relationship, showing that diversity (mean {pi} = 2.3x10-3) within species is similar, and that divergence between species is modest (weighted FST=0.4430). Individual accessions were homozygous for ancestral SNPs at over half of variable sites, while fixed, derived sites were at modest frequencies. Notably, two chromosomes with a paucity of fixed, derived sites (i.e., chromosomes 7 and 10) were also strongly implicated in introgression analyses. Collectively, these data demonstrate variable permeability to introgression among chromosomes, which we propose is due to divergent selection under domestication and/or the phenomenon of F2 breakdown in interspecific crosses. Our analyses provide insight into the evolutionary forces influencing diversity and divergence in the diploid cultivated species, and establish a foundation for understanding the contribution of introgression and/or strong parallel selection to the extensive morphological similarities shared between species. Significance statementThe cotton genus (Gossypium) contains four different species that were independently domesticated at least 4,000 years ago. Relatively little is understood about diversity and evolution in the two diploid African-Asian sister-species G. herbaceum and G. arboreum, despite their historical importance in the region and contemporary cultivation, largely in the Indian subcontinent. Here we address questions regarding the relationship between the two species, their contemporary levels of diversity, and their patterns of interspecific gene flow accompanying their several millennia history of human-mediated dispersal and contact. We validate independent domestication of the two species and document the genomic distribution of interspecific genetic exchange.