Assessment of MRI criteria for abnormal brain MRI in acute monosymptomatic optic neuritis. Comparison to findings in healthy persons

To evaluate various MRI criteria we studied a representative group of 149 consecutive patients below 50 years with acute monosymptomatic optic neuritis (AMON), a frequent first manifestation of multiple sclerosis (MS). The presence, number, size, and localization of areas of increased signal (AIS) on T2-weighted brain MRIs obtained at 1.5 T were described and compared with findings in 71 healthy persons aged 21–50 years without diabetes, cerebrovascular or neurologic diseases. MRI was performed within 2–145 days, median 16 days from onset of AMON and showed from 0 to 26 AIS, sized 2–30 mm, in 79 of 149 (53%) patients compared to 0–18 AIS, sized 2–12 mm, in 31 of 71 (44%) healthy persons. In patients, AIS were significantly more frequent in women than in men (χ2 = 4.67, p > 0.05). Periventricular AIS were revealed in 70 (47%) patients and in 14 (20%) healthy persons. Subcortical AIS were present in 5 (3%) patients and in 18 (25%) healthy persons. Infratentorial AIS were present in only 3 (2%) patients. The sensitivity and specificity of previously proposed diagnostic MRI criteria for MS were unsatisfactory in our group of patients and have previously only been validated in definite MS. We therefore constructed and tested four new sets of criteria. The set with the best relation between sensitivity (e.g. 41%) and specificity (e.g. 93%) was the following: presence of two or more AIS, of which at least one is periventricular or infratentorial, combined with the absence of subcortical AIS. These criteria are recommended for patients with AMON and might be used in other patients with possible or probable MS.