Compositional zoning of calcite in a high-pressure metamorphic calc-schist: clues to heterogeneous grain-scale fluid distribution during exhumation

Calcite in former aragonite–dolomite-bearing calc-schists from the ultrahigh-pressure metamorphic (UHPM) oceanic complex at Lago di Cignana, Valtournanche, Italy, preserved different kinds of zoning patterns at calcite grain and phase boundaries. These patterns are interpreted in terms of lattice diffusion and interfacial mass transport linked with a heterogeneous distribution of fluid and its response to a changing state of stress. The succession of events that occurred during exhumation is as follows: As the rocks entered the calcite stability field at T=530–550 °C, P ca. 1.2 GPa, aragonite occurring in the matrix and as inclusions in poikilitic garnet was completely transformed to calcite. Combined evidence from microstructures and digital element distribution maps (Mn-, Mg-, Fe- and Ca–Kα radiation intensity patterns) indicates that transformation rates have been much higher than rates of compositional equilibration of calcite (involving resorption of dolomite and grain boundary transport of Mg, Fe and Ca). This rendered the phase transformation an isochemical process. During subsequent cooling to T ca. 490 °C (where lattice diffusion effectively closed), grains of matrix calcite have developed diffusion-zoned rims, a few hundred micrometres thick, with Mg and Fe increasing and Ca decreasing towards the phase boundary. Composition profiles across concentrically zoned, large grains in geometrically simple surroundings can be successfully modelled with an error function describing diffusion into a semi-infinite medium from a source of constant composition. The diffusion rims in matrix calcite are continuous with quartz, phengite, paragonite and dolomite in the matrix. This points to an effective mass transport on phase boundaries over a distance of several hundred micrometres, if matrix dolomite has supplied the Mg and Fe needed for incorporation in calcite. In contrast, diffusion rims are lacking at calcite–calcite and most calcite–garnet boundaries, implying that only very minor mass transport has occurred on these interfaces over the same T–t interval. From available grain boundary diffusion data and experimentally determined fluid–solid grain boundary structures, inferred large differences in transport rates can be best explained by the discontinuous distribution of aqueous fluid along grain/phase boundaries. Observed patterns of diffusion zoning indicate that fluid was distributed not only along grain-edge channels, but spread out along most calcite–white mica and calcite–quartz two-grain junctions. On the other hand, the inferred non-wetting of calcite grain boundaries in carbonate-rich domains is compatible with fluid–calcite–calcite dihedral angles >60° determined by Holness and Graham (1995) for a wide range of fluid compositions under the P–T conditions of interest. Whereas differential stress has been very low at the stage of diffusion zoning (T > 490 °C), it increased as the rocks were cooling below 440 °C (at 0.3–0.5 GPa). Dislocation creep and the concomitant increase of strain energy in matrix calcite induced migration recrystallisation of high-angle grain boundaries. For that stage, the compositional microstructure of recrystallised calcite grain boundary domains indicates significant mass transport along calcite two-grain junctions, which at the established low temperatures is likely to have been accomplished by ionic diffusion within a hydrous grain boundary fluid film (“dynamic wetting” of migrating grain boundaries).