Decrease in SYM-H during a storm main phase without evidence of a ring current injection

Abstract Changes in the Dst index, or the similarly constructed high-resolution SYM-H index, are thought to indicate changes in the total energy content of the ring current. However, this is not always the case. In this paper we examine an intense (SYM-H ∼ −435 nT) magnetic storm that occurred on March 31, 2001. The arrival at Earth of strongly southward IMF produced an immediate negative response in the SYM-H index. While energetic particle and magnetometer data from geosynchronous orbit and inner magnetosphere energetic neutral atom imaging indicate that two substorm injections took place during the main phase, there was about one hour when the SYM-H decreased more than 200 nT with no evidence in the data for ring current enhancement. Instead the near-Earth magnetotail exhibited a growth phase indicative of a strong, growing cross-tail current, with the large substorm expansion phase and the associated injection of energetic particles coming significantly later. Data from the DMSP spacecraft demonstrate that the polar cap flux grew rapidly in response to the strongly southward IMF. We present observations showing that the decrease in SYM-H occurred when polar cap flux was increasing and there was no evidence of injection into the ring current. Our findings strongly support the relationship between Dst and the polar cap flux proposed by theoretical studies that determined that the tail current system could be a significant contributor to Dst.