Classical versus quantum dynamical chaos: Sensitivity to external perturbations, stability and reversibility

The extraordinary complexity of classical trajectories of typical nonlinear systems that manifest stochastic behavior is intimately connected with exponential sensitivity to small variations of initial conditions and/or weak external perturbations. In rigorous terms, such classical systems are characterized by positive algorithmic complexity described by the Lyapunov exponent or, alternatively, by the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy. The said implies that, in spite of the fact that, formally, any however complex trajectory of a perfectly isolated (closed) system is unique and differentiable for any certain initial conditions and the motion is perfectly reversible, it is impractical to treat that sort of classical systems as closed ones. Inevitably, arbitrary weak influence of an environment crucially impacts the dynamics. This influence, that can be considered as a noise, rapidly effaces the memory of initial conditions and turns the motion into an irreversible random process. In striking contrast, the quantum mechanics of the classically chaotic systems exhibit much weaker sensitivity and strong memory of the initial state. Qualitatively, this crucial difference could be expected in view of a much simpler structure of quantum states as compared to the extraordinary complexity of random and unpredictable classical trajectories. However the very notion of trajectories is absent in quantum mechanics so that the concept of exponential instability seems to be irrelevant in this case. The problem of a quantitative measure of complexity of a quantum state of motion, that is a very important and nontrivial issue of the theory of quantum dynamical chaos, is the one of our concern. With such a measure in hand, we quantitatively analyze the stability and reversibility of quantum dynamics in the presence of external noise. To solve this problem we point out that individual classical trajectories are of minor interest if the motion is chaotic. Properties of all of them are alike in this case and rather the behavior of their manifolds carries really valuable information. Therefore the phase-space methods and, correspondingly, the Liouville form of the classical mechanics become the most adequate. It is very important that, opposite to the classical trajectories, the classical phase space distribution and the Liouville equation have direct quantum analogs. Hence, the analogy and difference of classical and quantum dynamics can be traced by comparing the classical (W (I, θ; t)) and quantum (Wigner function W (I, θ; t)) phase space distributions both expressed in identical phase-space variables but ruled by different(!) linear equations. 2 V. V. Sokolov et al. The paramount property of the classical dynamical chaos is the exponentially fast structuring of the system’s phase space on finer and finer scales. On the contrary, degree of structuring of the corresponding Wigner function is restricted by the quantization of the phase space. This makes Wigner function more coarse and relatively ”simple” as compared to its classical counterpart. Fourier analysis affords quite suitable ground for analyzing complexity of a phase space distribution, that is equally valid in classical and quantum cases. We demonstrate that the typical number of Fourier harmonics is indeed a relevant measure of complexity of states of motion in both classical as well as quantum cases. This allowed us to investigate in detail and introduce a quantitative measure of sensitivity to an external noisy environment and formulate the conditions under which the quantum motion remains reversible. It turns out that while the mean number of harmonics of the classical phase-space distribution of a non-integrable system grows with time exponentially during the whole time of the motion, the time of exponential upgrowth of this number in the case of the corresponding quantum Wigner function is restricted only to the Ehrenfest interval 0 < t < tE just the interval within which the Wigner function still satisfies the classical Liouville equation. We showed that the number of harmonics increases beyond this interval algebraically. This fact gains a crucial importance when the Ehrenfest time is so short that the exponential regime has no time to show up. Under this condition the quantum motion turns out to be quite stable and reversible.