Binding and neutralization efficiencies of monoclonal antibodies, Fab fragments, and scFv specific for L1 epitopes on the capsid of infectious HPV particles

We compared the neutralization abilities of individual monoclonal antibodies (MAb) of two large panels reactive with L1 epitopes of HPV-11 or HPV-16. Binding titers were compared using both L1-only VLPs and to L1/L2 pseudovirions. While the VLPs were antigenically similar to the pseudovirions, clear differences in the surface exposure of some epitopes were evident with the HPV-16 particles. To determine whether all antibody binding events are equivalent in their neutralizing effect on infectious HPV virions or pseudovirions, the binding and neutralization titers for individual MAbs were used to calculate the relative neutralization efficiency for each antibody. HPV neutralization was achieved by all MAbs capable of strong binding to either linear or conformation-sensitive epitopes on pseudovirus particles. Our data suggest, however, that some L1 epitopes may be more neutralization-sensitive than other surface epitopes, in that successful infection can be blocked by varying degrees of epitope saturation. Additionally, the effective neutralization of virions by several monovalent Fab fragments and single chain variable fragments (scFv) demonstrates that viral neutralization does not require HPV particle aggregation or L1 crosslinking. Identification of capsid protein structures rich in neutralization-sensitive epitopes may aid in the development of improved recombinant vaccines capable of eliciting effective and long-term antibody-mediated protection against multiple HPV types.