Environment dependent benefits of individual differences in the recruitment behaviour of honey bees

Inter-individual differences in behaviour within the members of a social group can affect the group9s productivity. In eusocial insects, individual differences amongst workers in a colony play a central role division of labour and task allocation. Extensive empirical and theoretical work has highlighted variation in response thresholds as a proximate mechanism underlying individual behavioural differences and hence division of labour. However, other response parameters, like response probability and intensity, can affect these differences. In this study, we first extended a previously published agent-based model on honey bee foraging to understand the relative importance of response (dance) probability and response (dance) intensity in the task of recruitment. Comparing variation obtained from the simulations with previously published empirical data, we found that response intensity plays a more important role than probability in producing consistent inter-individual differences in recruitment behaviour. We then explored the benefits provided by this individual variation in recruitment behaviour to the colony9s collective foraging effort under different environmental conditions. Our results revealed that individual variation leads to a greater energetic yield per forager, but only when food is abundant. Our study highlights the need to consider all response parameters while studying division of labour and adds to the growing body of evidence linking individual variation in behavioural responses to the success of social groups.