Toward the Unambiguous Identification of Supermassive Binary Black Holes through Bayesian Inference

Supermassive binary black holes at sub-parsec orbital separations have yet to be discovered, with the possible exception of blazar OJ~287. In parallel to the global hunt for nanohertz gravitational waves from supermassive binaries using pulsar timing arrays, there has been a growing sample of candidates reported from electromagnetic surveys, particularly searches for periodic variations in optical light curves of quasars. However, the periodicity search is prone to false positives from quasar red noise and quasi-periodic oscillations from the accretion disc of a single supermassive black hole---especially when the data span fewer than a few signal cycles. We present a Bayesian method for the detection of quasar (quasi-)periodicity in the presence of red noise. We apply this method to the binary candidate PG1302$-$102, and show that a) there is very strong support (Bayes factor $>10^6$) for quasi-periodicity, and b) the data slightly favour a quasi-periodic oscillation over a sinusoidal signal, which we interpret as modest evidence against the binary black hole hypothesis. We also find that the prevalent damped random walk red-noise model is disfavored with more than 99.9\% credibility. Finally, we outline future work that may enable the unambiguous identification of supermassive binary black holes.