Differentiation in Leaf Physiological Traits Related to Shade and Drought Tolerance Underlies Contrasting Adaptations of Two Cyclobalanopsis (Fagaceae) Species at the Seedling Stage

Adaptation and acclimation of tree seedlings to different combinations of light and water conditions can determine the species-specific patterns of distribution along environmental gradients and the underlying physiological mechanisms are fundamental to the understanding of such patterns. Seedlings of two Cyclobalanopsis species naturally occurring in southwest China, with distinct distribution and regeneration characteristics, were grown under 100%, 50% and 4% sunlight conditions and traits related to shade and drought tolerance were studied. Particularly, we investigated whether leaf hydraulics, photosynthetic traits and their functional coordination play an important role in determining seedling environmental adaptation and acclimation of the two species. Seedlings of C. helferiana showed characteristics adapted to high irradiance while C. rex had traits adapted to partially shaded environments. Cyclobalanopsis helferiana had significantly higher maximum net photosynthetic rate (Amax), light compensation point and light saturation point than C. rex and the contrasts were particularly large when they were grown under full sunlight. Cyclobalanopsis helferiana showed the highest Amax when grown under 100% sunlight, while C. rex exhibited the highest Amax at 50% sunlight. Similarly, under full sunlight conditions C. helferiana showed significantly higher leaf hydraulic conductance (Kleaf) than C. rex, i.e., 13.37 vs. 7.09 mmol m−2 s−1 MPa−1 (p < 0.01). The correlation between Kleaf and Amax followed a unified positive correlation across different light treatments of both species. Moreover, leaves of C. helferiana showed greater resistance to drought-induced hydraulic dysfunction and to desiccation than C. rex. The contrasts in functional traits between the two Cyclobalanopsis species are consistent with the hypothesis that there is a trade-off between shade tolerance and drought tolerance. Findings of the present study contribute to a deeper understanding of mechanisms of divergence between closely related (congeneric) species with respect to key ecophysiology associated with natural regeneration.