Association Between C5 Palsy and the Anterior Decompression Procedures, Corpectomy and Discectomy.

STUDY DESIGN This is a retrospective study. OBJECTIVE The aim was to evaluate the influence of various decompression procedures on the incidence of C5 palsy (C5P). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA C5P is a well-known but unsolved complication of cervical spine surgery. Among anterior cervical decompressive procedures, both corpectomy and discectomy are important surgical methods, whose effects on the incidence of C5P are unknown. METHODS We retrospectively analyzed 818 patients (529 men; mean age: 59.2±11.6 y) who underwent anterior cervical decompression and fusion. The surgical choice to use corpectomy, discectomy, or hybrid decompression was based on standard treatment strategies depending on local compressive pathology and presenting clinical symptoms. We introduced an original "decompression combination score" as a means of quantifying the effects of the procedures on the development of C5P. The scores were based on the relative severity of various risk factors associated with the eventual development of C5P and were assigned as follows: C4 corpectomy, 1 point; C5 corpectomy, 1 point; C3 corpectomy successive to C4 corpectomy, 0.5 point; C6 or C7 corpectomy successive to C5 corpectomy, 0.5 point; C4/5 discectomy, 0.5 point; discectomy at another segment, 0 point. Each patient's decompression combination score was then comprised of the sum of these points. RESULTS C5P occurred in 55 (47 men, mean age: 65.7±8.7 y) of the 818 (6.7%) patients. A larger number of operated disc segments was significantly associated with C5P. Higher decompression combination score was significantly associated with C5P. Multivariate analysis revealed that male sex, higher decompression combination score, and older age were significant risk factors. CONCLUSIONS Corpectomy increased the incidence of C5P, while discectomy decreased the risk. The lower incidence of postoperative C5P after discectomy may be because of minimizing tethering effect to the C5 nerve root. As a preventive measure against C5P, corpectomy should be avoided, while discectomy is recommended as much as possible. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE Levels of Evidence: Step IV-Oxford Center for Evidence-Based Medicine 2011.