Quantitation of Ki-67 expression in the differential diagnosis of reserve cell hyperplasia vs. small cell lung carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether the detection of proliferation-associated Ki-67 antigen may be of value in differentiating between reserve cell hyperplasia (RCH) and small cell lung cancer (SCLC). STUDY DESIGN: Retrospectively, 20 Papanicolaou-stained bronchial brushes or washings from 20 patients were selected. Ten were diagnosed as RCH (and had no SCLC in follow-up) and the other 10 as SCLC (histologically confirmed). All 20 Papanicolaou-stained slides were restained with the monoclonal antibody MIB1, directed against Ki-67 antigen; that simple and reliable procedure was described recently. In each specimen 5 coherent cell groups were identified, corresponding to RCH or SCLC, respectively; photographed; and studied for Ki-67 antigen expression after MIB1 staining of the slides. At least 3 cell groups remained in each specimen. The Ki-67 labeling index (LI) of the specimens was determined as the number of MIB1-positive cells divided by the total number of cells in the remaining cell groups. RESULTS: All cases of SCLC showed a mean Ki-67 LI of at least .415 (mean .684, SD .151), whereas in the cases with RCH the mean Ki-67 LI never was more than .158 (mean .048, SD .049). The difference was highly significant (P<.001, Student's t test). Linear discriminant analysis resulted in a classifier with which we were able to discriminate correctly between SCLC and RCH in 100% of the 20 bronchial brushings and washings. CONCLUSION: The results clearly demonstrate that measuring proliferative activity in Papanicolaou-stained bronchial brushings and washings by MIB1 restaining of the slides may be of great practical value in accurately discriminating RCH from SCLC. The method is simple and can be performed in any laboratory that is able to carry out immunocytochemical staining. However, an additional (prospective) study with a series of difficult cases is necessary to confirm these findings.