In vitro permeation of repellent DEET and sunscreen oxybenzone across three artificial membranes

DEET and oxybenzone are two essential active ingredients in repellent and sunscreen products. We performed a series of in vitro diffusion studies to evaluate the transmembrane permeation of DEET and oxybenzone across three artificial membranes, low-density polyethylene (LDPE), low fouling composite (LFC) and mixed cellulose esters (MCE), from concurrent use of commercial repellent and sunscreen preparations. Permeation of DEET and oxybenzone across the test membranes was synergistically increased when both the repellent and the sunscreen formulations were applied simultaneously. Different application sequences and formulation types also resulted in variable permeation profiles of DEET and oxybenzone. Compared to biological piglet epidermis under the identical experimental conditions, transmembrane permeation of DEET was suppressed in LDPE and LFC membranes, but enhanced in MCE membrane; transmembrane permeation of oxybenzone was reduced in LFC membrane, but increased in LDPE and MCE membranes. Permeability coefficients of DEET and oxybenzone in all three artificial membranes were significantly different from those in piglet skin. It was concluded that the permeation profiles of the compounds were dependent upon physicochemical characteristics of the membranes and the formulations.