Performance evaluation of CoAP, SNMP and NETCONF protocols in fog computing architecture

Different architectures of interactions between the objects in the Internet of Things have been proposed, based on direct exchange of data between the wireless devices or based on synchronization with fixed network devices or cloud infrastructure. We evaluated how the selection of the communication architecture influences the performance of the data exchange using discrete event simulation. The distribution of time needed to pass information between smart objects is calculated for three popular network management protocols: CoAP, SNMP and NETCONF. The evaluation is executed for 3 types of communication proposed in the fog computing paradigm: direct synchronization between devices, synchronization through the local gateway or synchronization via the cloud servers. The analysis shows that the communication via the cloud infrastructure requires up to the three times longer time than the data exchange through a local gateway and up to 6 times longer than the direct communication between the network nodes. Transmission through CoAP and SNMP introduces similar delay, considerably lower than NETCONF.