Performance Impact Analysis of Securing MQTT Using TLS

The interconnectivity of devices on the Internet of Things (IoT) provides many new and smart applications. However, the integration of many devices - especially by inexperienced users - might introduce several security threats. Further, several often used communication protocols in the IoT domain are not out-of-the-boxsecured. On the other hand, security inherently introduces overhead, resulting in a decrease in performance. The Message QueuingTelemetry Transport (MQTT) protocol is a popular communication protocol for IoT applications - for example, in Industry 4.0, railways, automotive, or smart homes. This paper analyzes the influence on performance when using MQTT with TLS in terms of throughput, connection build-up times, and energy efficiency using a reproducible testbed based on a standard off-the-shelf microcontroller. The results indicate that the impact of TLS on performance across all QoS levels depends on (i) the network situation and (ii) the connection reestablishment frequency. Thus, a negative influence of TLS on the performance is noticeable only in deteriorated networksituations or at a high connection reestablishment frequency.