Implications of quantitative tumor and nodal regression rates for nasopharyngeal carcinomas after 45 Gy of radiotherapy

Purpose: To quantitatively investigate the clinical implications of tumor regression rate (TRR-45) and nodal regression rate (NRR-45) of nasopharyngeal carcinomas (NPC) after receiving 45 Gy of radiotherapy (RT). The values, predictive values, and associated factors of TRR-45 and NRR-45 in NPC are analyzed. Methods and Materials: One hundred one patients with newly diagnosed NPC and who were curatively treated by RT alone were included in the study. Tumor volume and nodal volume before treatment and after 45 Gy were obtained from computed tomographic (CT) scans performed at those times and calculated with the assistance of a computer-based imaging analyzing system. TRR-45 (NRR-45) was defined as the ratio of reduced tumor (nodal) volume after 45 Gy to the initial tumor (nodal) volume. TRR-45 (NRR-45) values were stratified into three groups of slow (below 50%), moderate (between 50% and 75%), and rapid (above 75%) change. After conventional RT with 45 Gy, conformal RT for primary tumors was boosted to 70.2‐72 Gy for T1‐2 tumors, and 75.6 ‐ 81 Gy for T3-T4 tumors. RT for residual neck masses was boosted by electron beam to 61‐75 Gy. Results: The mean value of TRR-45 for all patients was lower than that of NRR-45 for the 78 patients with metastatic neck nodes (70% 6 4.8% vs. 81% 6 5%, p 5 0.003). The 3-year actuarial neck control rate was better than the primary tumor control rate with statistical significance (98% vs. 85%, p 5 0.009). No significant statistical differences concerning local control probability, nodal control probability, or survival rate were found among patients with slow, moderate, or rapid TRR-45 or NRR-45. T-stage was the only significant prognostic factor for locoregional control after multivariate analysis. Tumor volume and T-stage were found to have a statistically significant negative correlation with TRR-45. No associated factor was found to be significantly correlated with NRR-45. Conclusion: Slow regression rates of the primary tumor or neck nodes in NPC after receiving 45 Gy of irradiation do not mean ultimately poor radiocurability, but may merely imply slow clearance of the cells damaged during irradiation. The different radiobiological behaviors of the regression rates during treatment, ultimate control probabilities, or associated factors for regression rates of NPC between primary tumors and neck nodes need to be further investigated. © 2001 Elsevier Science Inc.