Determination of the degree of reaction of fly ash in blended cement pastes
2015
This paper gives a review over methods to determine the degree of reaction for supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) with focus on Portland cement - fly ash blends only and summarizes and highlights the most important findings which are detailed in a parallel paper published in Materials and Structures.
Determination of the extent of the reaction of SCMs in mixtures is complicated for several reasons: (1) the physical presence of SCMs affects the rate and extent of the reaction of the ground clinker component – the so called “filler effect”; (2) SCMs are usually amorphous with complex and varied mineralogy which make them difficult to quantify by many classical techniques such as X-ray diffraction; (3) the rate of reaction of SCMs in a cement blend may be quite different from its rate of reaction in systems containing simply alkali or lime.
From this review it is clear that measuring the degree of reaction of SCMs remains challenging. Nevertheless progress has been made in recent years to offer alternatives to the traditional selective dissolution methods. Unfortunately some of these – image analysis and EDS mapping in the scanning electron microscope, and NMR - depend on access to expensive equipment and are time consuming. With regard to fly ashes, NMR seems to be reliable but limited to fly ash with low iron content. New methods with quantitative EDS mapping to segment fly ash particles from the hydrated matrix and to follow the reaction of glass groups of disparate composition separately look very promising, but time consuming. Sources with a high proportion of fine particles will have higher errors due to lower limit of resolution (1-2 μm). Whereas for SCMs which react relatively fast (e.g. slag, calcined clay) the methods based on calorimetry and chemical shrinkage seem promising on a comparative basis, the very low reaction degree of fly ashes before 28 days means that the calorimetry method is not practical. There is a lack of data to assess the usefulness of long term chemical shrinkage measurements. The possibility to quantify the amorphous phase by XRD is promising as this is a widely available and rapid technique which can at the same time give a wealth of additional information on the phases formed. However, the different reaction rates of different glasses in compositionally heterogeneous fly ashes will need to be accounted for and may strongly reduce the accuracy of the profile decomposition method.
This paper is the work of working group 2 of the RILEM TC 238-SCM “Hydration and microstructure of concrete with supplementary cementitious materials”.
Keywords:
- Correction
- Source
- Cite
- Save
- Machine Reading By IdeaReader
18
References
4
Citations
NaN
KQI