Comparison of Two Public Sector Tertiary Care Hospitals’ Management in Reducing Direct Medical Cost Burden on Breast Carcinoma Patients in Lahore, Pakistan

Purpose: Breast cancer is one of the major causes of death incurring highest morbidity and mortality amongst women of Pakistan. The purpose of this study was to assess and compare the role of two public sector tertiary care hospitals’ management in reducing out of pocket (OOP) expenses on direct medical costs borne by breast carcinoma patients’ household from diagnosis through treatment. Moreover, the study intended to explore the reasons of opting private diagnostic facilities by the said patients during the services taken from the foresaid tertiary care centers. Methods: A purposive sample of 164 primary breast carcinoma patients was recruited for data collection of this cross-sectional study. Face to face interviews and semi structured questionnaires were adopted as method of data gathering tools. Major cost components of direct medical costs were used to compare the financial strain on the patients’ households of both targeted hospitals. In addition, information was collected regarding the reasons of opting private diagnostic centers for investigations. Frequency, percentages, median and inter quartile range (IQR) were calculated for the data. Non-parametric variables were compared using the Mann-Whitney U test. Results: It was observed that overall direct medical cost borne by the breast carcinoma patients’ households in Jinnah hospital (median US$1153.93/Rs. 118,589) was significantly higher than Mayo hospital (median US$427.93/Rs. 43,978), p<0.001; r=0.623. Moreover, spending on almost all of the components of direct medical cost were found smaller in case of Mayo hospital’s patients as compared to Jinnah hospital. Conclusion: This study indicates that OOP direct medical cost burden was found considerably less in Mayo hospital as compared to Jinnah hospital. The OOP expenditures on chemotherapy were overwhelmingly high. However, high spending on privately opted investigations procedures was the common issue of the patients under treatment in both hospitals.