Large single-locus effects for maturation timing are mediated via condition variation in Atlantic salmon

Sexual maturation is a pivotal life-history trait that balances the probabilities between mortality and reproduction. Environmental vs. genetic contributions to maturation component traits, such as somatic growth and body condition, remain uncertain because of difficulties in determining causality. In Atlantic salmon, maturation timing associates with a large-effect locus around vgll3, which also links with growth, condition, and maturation in mammals. We investigate environmental vs. genetic contributions to maturation and its component traits by combining controlled breeding with common-garden experimentation in two temperatures. We test whether vgll3 associates with first-year maturation of male salmon and, to avoid reverse causality, whether vgll3 effects express via growth or condition in the males9 non-maturing female relatives. Across 41 families, 4% of males matured in the cold vs. 39% in the warm environment. Maturation rate differed 3.3- to 4.6-fold between vgll3 genotypes, which also explained around 30% of maturation heritability. Female condition differed up to 2% between vgll3 genotypes, which also explained 6-17% of condition heritability. Non-significant vgll3 effects on female length were antagonistic to those for condition but of equal proportional size. When accounting for vgll3 effects, positive genetic correlations between male maturation and female growth increased, whereas those between male maturation and condition decreased, supporting an antagonistic effect of vgll3 on growth and condition. The results indicate that large vgll3 effects on maturation are mediated via large condition effects and suggest vgll3 as a candidate locus for controlling the resource allocation trade-off between somatic growth and body condition.