Comparative analysis of zooplankton diversity in freshwaters: What can we gain from metagenomic analysis?

Molecular genetic approaches applied to environmental DNA have great potential for biodiversity research and ecosystem monitoring. A metagenome contains genetic information from all organisms captured in an environmental sample. It has been primarily used to study bacteria and archaea, but promising reports focusing on metazoan diversity are emerging. However, methodological uncertainties remain, and studies are required to validate the power and the limitations of such an approach when applied to macro-eukaryotes. Here, we analyzed water sample metagenomes to estimate zooplankton diversity in 22 freshwater lakes across Eastern Canada. We tested the coherence of data based on morphologically identified zooplankton taxa and molecular genetic data derived from shotgun sequencing of environmental DNA collected at the same time. RV coefficients showed a significant correlation between the relative abundance of zooplankton families derived from small subunit rRNA genes extracted from the metagenomes and morphologically identified zooplankton. However, differences in congruence with morphological counts were detected when varied bioinformatic approaches were applied to presence-absence data. This study presents one of the first diversity assessments of a group of aquatic metazoans using metagenomes and validates the coherence of the community composition derived from genetic and classical species surveys. Overall, our results suggest that metagenomics has the potential to be further developed to describe metazoan biodiversity in aquatic ecosystems, and to advance this area we provide key recommendations for workflow improvement.