Opposite impacts of K+ and Ca2+ on membrane fouling by humic acid and cleaning process: Evaluation and mechanism investigation

Abstract Understanding the influences of cations on membrane fouling was important to improve the performance of membrane filtration system, however, opposite conclusions were made in different studies. Meanwhile, although the influences of cation concentration have been studied extensively, few attentions have been paid to the cation valence. To clarify it, the effects of typical cations on membrane fouling and cleaning, as well as the related mechanisms were investigated systemically in this study. K+ and Ca2+ were chosen as the representative cations, and humic acid (HA) was chosen as the membrane foulants. The results demonstrated Ca2+ promoted the formation of reversible fouling, meanwhile higher removal efficiency of HA could also be achieved with the assistance of filtration cake containing HA + Ca2+. However, K+ led to the formation of more recalcitrant irreversible fouling. By comparing the concentration of cations in feed and permeate, analyzing the influence of cations on size of HA flocs, and the detailed SEM, AFM and TEM observation, it could be found that different mechanisms dominated the interaction between cations and HA. The bridging effect induced by Ca2+ attributed to the extension of HA molecules, while the electrostatic shielding effect induced by K+ led to the compression of them. Moreover, the different characteristics of hydrated Ca2+ and K+ also contributed to the different structures of foulant layers formed by HA + Ca2+ and HA + K+. Given the abundance of K+ and Ca2+ in natural water, results of this study can provide valuable advice for practical membrane filtration process.